نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسنده English
Introduction
The Delphi method is one of the most widely used expert-based approaches in futures studies, strategic planning, technology assessment, policy analysis, and social sciences. Initially developed as a systematic technique for obtaining expert judgments and reaching informed consensus, the method has gradually evolved into a flexible framework for exploring alternative futures, forecasting technological developments, developing scenarios, and supporting policy and strategic decision-making.
Despite its broad international application, limited familiarity with the theoretical foundations, methodological requirements, and contemporary variations of the Delphi method has contributed to its relatively limited or inconsistent application among some Iranian researchers. This study therefore examines the theoretical and methodological development of Delphi and its applications, with particular attention to developments between 2021 and 2026. It also considers relevant international literature published between 2020 and 2025 and compares the development of Delphi applications in Iran with international practices.
In contemporary futures research, several complementary methods are used to explore possible, probable, and desirable futures, including environmental scanning, trend analysis, relevance trees, scenario building, visioning, Causal Layered Analysis (CLA), regression analysis, and Delphi. Within this methodological landscape, Delphi has become particularly important because it enables researchers to systematically collect, compare, refine, and aggregate expert judgments concerning uncertain future developments.
Research Method
This study employed a qualitative, library-based and documentary research approach. Relevant academic literature, methodological publications, and Iranian studies applying the Delphi method were identified, reviewed, classified, and analyzed. Data collection was conducted through systematic note-taking, followed by descriptive and comparative analysis of the selected materials.
The analysis focused on major methodological dimensions of Delphi research, including the identification and selection of experts, the quality and formulation of research statements, the number and structure of Delphi rounds, controlled feedback, consensus criteria, assessment of methodological quality, and the use of contemporary digital technologies.
The study also examined different applications of Delphi in Iran, including research conducted in the fields of sports, culture, the judiciary, industry, and other social and organizational contexts. To enhance the credibility and validity of the findings, the results and interpretations were presented to five university professors specializing in research methodology. Their comments and evaluations were incorporated into the final analysis.
Findings
The findings indicate that the Delphi method has undergone a substantial transformation from a traditional technique for achieving expert consensus into a broader and more flexible framework for futures studies, scenario development, technology forecasting, policy analysis, and strategic planning. The literature reviewed between 2020 and 2025 demonstrates increasing methodological attention to expert selection, statement quality, consensus measurement, study quality assessment, and technological integration.
One of the most important findings concerns the central role of expert selection. Since Delphi findings depend substantially on the knowledge, experience, and future-oriented judgment of participants, establishing transparent criteria for expert identification and recruitment is essential. Expert selection should therefore be regarded as a fundamental component of research design rather than merely a sampling procedure.
The Delphi process is generally longitudinal because data are collected through several successive rounds. Participants respond to questions or statements, receive controlled feedback based on the aggregated responses, and are then given the opportunity to reconsider or modify their judgments. This iterative structure enables researchers to examine convergence, stability, and disagreement over time.
Anonymity is another important characteristic of Delphi. Because participants normally do not interact directly with one another, the method can reduce the effects of social pressure, professional hierarchy, dominant personalities, and conformity. This creates greater opportunity for participants to express independent or dissenting judgments.
The study also identifies six major forms of Delphi: classical Delphi, modified Delphi, electronic Delphi, fuzzy Delphi, policy Delphi, and ranking Delphi. These variants demonstrate the adaptability of the method to different research objectives and methodological contexts.
The Iranian literature indicates that Delphi has been applied in diverse fields, including sports, culture, the judiciary, and industry. However, comparison with international research suggests that the international application of Delphi has generally progressed further in terms of methodological diversification, digital integration, quality assessment, expert-selection procedures, and explicit criteria for determining consensus.
Results and Conclusion
The results demonstrate that the contemporary Delphi method should not be understood merely as a mechanism for obtaining agreement among experts. Rather, it represents a structured and iterative approach for eliciting, evaluating, refining, and integrating expert knowledge under conditions of uncertainty.
The combination of qualitative expert judgment with quantitative analytical procedures is one of the method's major strengths. Although the primary data are generated through expert judgments, these data can subsequently be analyzed using numerical indicators such as frequencies, rankings, means, medians, and measures of agreement. Delphi can therefore provide a methodological bridge between qualitative knowledge and quantitative analysis.
The growing use of electronic platforms has further expanded the potential of Delphi. Digital technologies facilitate communication with geographically dispersed experts, accelerate successive rounds, simplify data management, and enable more efficient analysis. Nevertheless, technological tools cannot compensate for weaknesses in research design. The validity of a Delphi study continues to depend heavily on appropriate expert selection, clear statement formulation, transparent procedures, and well-defined consensus criteria.
For Iranian researchers, greater methodological attention should therefore be devoted to these dimensions. In particular, future Delphi studies should clearly justify the selection of experts, define the research time horizon, report the number and characteristics of participants, specify the criteria for consensus, document the process of controlled feedback, and distinguish between genuine consensus and persistent disagreement.
In conclusion, the evolution of Delphi from a conventional consensus-building technique into a multidimensional foresight framework demonstrates its continuing relevance to contemporary research. Its applications in futures studies, communication, media, technology assessment, policy analysis, and strategic planning make it particularly valuable for examining complex problems for which historical evidence alone is insufficient. Strengthening the methodological rigor of Delphi research in Iran and incorporating contemporary international developments can contribute significantly to the quality and credibility of future-oriented research.
Keywords
Delphi Method; Delphi Foresight; Futures Studies; Expert Consensus; Expert Panel; Technology Assessment; Policy Delphi; Scenario Building; Technology Forecasting; Longitudinal Research